Aalto Doctoral Programme in Electrical Engineering
Doctoral thesis
Forms of doctoral theses in the School of Electrical Engineering
An approved doctoral thesis may be:
- A monograph
- An article-based doctoral thesis
Essay-based theses and other works meeting corresponding scientific criteria are not accepted as doctoral theses in the School of Electrical Engineering.
A monograph is a coherent writing based on the research work of the doctoral student and written by the student. It is recommended that the author has scientific publications related to the monograph and that these publications have been published in peer-reviewed fora.
The monograph
- must contain new scientific findings
- does not include a separate list of the author´s own publications, but if the student has publications, they can be referred to in the reference list as the other references
- describes the research problem, the research goals, the methods used, the results of the research and presents a summary of the key findings.
Provided that the scope of the research question is reasonably sized and well defined, a thesis research aiming at a monograph, with the related reports, is usually faster and easier to carry out than an article-based thesis. Defining the research scope for a monograph thesis is often considered easier than for an article-based thesis. However, the evaluation of a monograph is more difficult in practice; such works require more often corrections and changes at the evaluation stage, which means that the review process becomes longer. The Committee may return an excessively long thesis to the writer obliging him or her to shorten it before it can be processed. The doctoral candidate shall concentrate on the essentials and present the material in a concise and structured manner. The Committee considers 300 pages a normal maximum limit. The doctoral thesis shall contain new scientific information in its discipline; it is inappropriate to broadly repeat generally known textbook facts.
Examination: Examining a monograph requires particular precision and carefulness, since the content is examined as something new, unlike in the case of an article-based thesis where the articles have already undergone a scientific peer-review process.
An article-based thesis contains a sufficient number of publications on a related set of problems and a summary part (compiling part).
The publications in an article-based thesis:
- are published, accepted for publication, or submitted for publication. At least one publication has been published or accepted for publication when the manuscript is submitted for pre-examination, the rest may be submitted for publication.
- are published in / submitted to acknowledged peer-reviewed international venues of the discipline (scientific journals, conference proceedings or other venues). It is recommended that at least one publication is published in / submitted to a scientific journal. The doctoral student must upon request provide proof of the peer-review process of the publications included in the thesis.
- is recommended to be 3-5 publications (depending on the field). The number of publications required varies though, depending on the extent, scientific significance and quality of the publications, and the doctoral student’s personal contribution to them.
- are recommended to be publications where the doctoral student is a main author. Publications where the contribution of the author has not been significant are to be left out, unless the publication is necessary for the storytelling and making the thesis a whole.
- must contain new scientific findings. A literature review may be included, if it contains new scientific findings.
- can be included in several theses if the separate contribution of the doctoral student can be demonstrated.
Extended conference abstracts (1–2 page summaries), standards, and patents cannot be included in article-based theses.
The summary part of the article-based thesis:
- is an independent entity, which provides an overview of the content of the thesis, but does not go too much into the details.
- is recommended to be 30-60 pages long, starting from the introduction and including the references.
- describes the research problem, research goals and methods, and presents a summary of the key findings.
- shall contain a list of the publications included in the thesis and describe the independent contribution of the doctoral student in each publication separately.
An article-based thesis creates motivating intermediary goals and provides an opportunity for the candidate to receive feedback and critique on the research work from the academic community throughout the writing process. Writing an article-based doctoral thesis is usually found to be an efficient way to learn how to compose scientific publications. Such a doctoral thesis is also easier to evaluate because the articles have already been through an evaluation process. In an article-based thesis, the new scientific knowledge should be contained primarily in the articles.
Examination: In an article-based doctoral thesis, at least one of the articles has already undergone the peer review and been published. The examination is directed on the summary part and articles as whole.
Doctoral thesis work
The topic of your doctoral thesis is approved by the Doctoral Programme Committee of the School when you are accepted to the doctoral programme. Your research plan is the basis for your thesis work.
Read more on page Doctoral thesis at Aalto University
Stepwise instructions for finalising the doctoral thesis
Before pre-examination
When you are approaching pre-examination, please familiarize yourself with the materials below.
During pre-examination
While your manuscript is being pre-examined, familiarize yourself with the next steps and read at least the materials listed below. You can also prepare for media coverage for your thesis, and make a draft of your lectio praecursoria.
Before public defence
The instructions for final steps before the defence are listed below. Check also relevant parts of the instructions on the previous section (permissions for publishing given, etc.).
Next public defences at the School of Electrical Engineering
Public defence in Radio Science and Engineering, Lic.Sc.(Tech.) Veli Voipio
The Gopher Antenna: A New Type of Ground Penetrating Radar Antenna (title of the thesis)Public defence in Automation Technology, M.Sc. David Leal Martinez
Design and optimization of a decentralized multi robot exploration behavior taking into account energy constraints (title of the thesis)Public defence in Measurement Science and Technology, M.Sc. Kinza Maham
Improved Calibration and Uncertainty Estimation Methods for Optical Radiometry (title of the thesis)Public defence in Electronics integration and reliability, M.Sc. Fahimeh Emadi
Contact Metallization Design for Low-Temperature Interconnects in MEMS Integration (title of the thesis)Licentiate thesis
Please read more about licentiate thesis via the links below
- Published:
- Updated: